Skip to main content

Best Italian Restaurant in Sarasota

Your New Favorite Spot for Rustic, Soul-Warming Italian Eats
Welcome to Maestrale Restaurant & Pizzeria

Welcome to Maestrale Restaurant & Pizzeria

Step into the heart of Italy right here in Sarasota. At Maestrale, every dish is crafted with passion, tradition, and the warm hospitality that makes you feel instantly at home. Join us for a comforting Italian experience made with family-style love.
Crafted With Flavor, Served With Soul

Crafted With Flavor, Served With Soul

Indulge in vibrant, comforting Italian creations that feel like a warm hug. From sizzling oven magic to plates layered with rich, aromatic goodness—every bite is designed to make your cravings sparkle. Elegant, cozy, and a little bit addictive… just the way comfort food should be.

Order From Our Website

Enjoy your Maestrale favorites from the comfort of your home. With easy online ordering, fast prep, and the same homemade quality you love, satisfying your Italian cravings is just a click away.
Ready to Reserve Your Table?

Ready to Reserve Your Table?

Make your visit unforgettable by securing your spot at Maestrale. Whether you're planning a cozy dinner, a celebration, or a simple night out, we’ll have a warm Italian welcome waiting just for you. Reserve now and let us take care of the rest.
A Place For Everyone

A Place For Everyone

From relaxing outdoor seating to comforting vegan-friendly choices, we welcome every guest with open arms. Whether you’re soaking in the fresh air or exploring wholesome, plant-forward options, there’s always something here to make you feel right at home.

Visit Us Today!! 🍽️

Experience warm Italian hospitality any day of the week. Whether you're joining us for a cozy dinner or a weekend night out, our doors are open to welcome you with comfort and flavor. Hours: • Monday: Closed • Tuesday: Closed • Wednesday: 5–9 PM • Thursday: 5–9 PM • Friday: 5–10 PM • Saturday: 5–10 PM • Sunday: 5–9 PM

Absolutely wonderful all around. Highly recommend this place. They make their deserts every day. I love gorgonzola gnocchi and it's so tough to find and theirs was out of this world. My 2nd favorite is tiramisu which is rarely made in house. Theirs is and it's out of this world good.

Bradley B.

What a fantastic dining experience! The food was absolutely amazing, and the atmosphere was very warm and welcoming. The service was excellent from start to finish. Everything we tried were delicious. Special notes to the lasagna which was fantastic—comforting, flavorful, and clearly made with care. I also tried the Gnocchi Gorgonzola (substituted with penne pasta), and it was out of this world. Rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced. The portions were very generous, which was a pleasant surprise. To top it all off, the lemon sorbet was a refreshing and delightful end to the meal. If you're in Sarasota, this spot is a must-try. We’ll definitely be back!

Jane P.

This is absolutely worth a try! Family-owned and intimate table settings ensure the ambiance is what you’re looking for in a lovely evening. The service was outstanding. Alfredo was charming and provided the specials for the evening. The Osso bucco with risotto was cooked to fall-off the bone perfection. Gnocchi is house-made and all were soft as pillows. From the fresh foccia to the pistachio cake and the most delicious cappuccino, the meal was phenomenal. No pictures of entrees because they were eaten too quickly! I will be back again soon! Meatballs, burrata, beef carpaccio as appetizers were delicious.

Ali F.

Featuring

Delivery

Takeout

Dine In

Reservations

Outdoor Seating

Vegan Options

Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Frequently Asked Questions

What are you known for?

We’re known for Italian pizzas, hearty pastas, seafood, chicken classics, and desserts from homemade tiramisu to gelato in Sarasota.

  • Italian Food: Italian favorites span pizza, pasta, seafood, chicken and veal dishes, with antipasti and traditional desserts rounding out the meal. Examples include Maestrale Pizza, Lasagna Emiliana, Linguine Alle Vongole, Chicken Parmigiana, Tagliere All'italiana, and Tiramisu’ Homemade.
  • Desserts: Sweet finishes include Italian pastries, chocolate and pistachio cakes, citrus treats, and gelato served on its own or with coffee. Examples include Cannolo, Lava Cake, Pistachio Cake, Lemon sorbe’, Gelato Affogato Al Caffe, and Tiramisu’ Homemade.
  • Pasta: Pasta dishes feature seafood linguine, meat-sauce fettuccine, vegetable preparations, cheese-sauced gnocchi, and layered lasagna. Examples include Linguine Pescatore, Fettuccine Bolognese, Pasta Ortolana, Gnocchi Gorgonzola, and Lasagna Emiliana.
  • Pizza: Italian-style pizzas range from four-cheese and vegetable varieties to prosciutto-topped options. Examples include Maestrale Pizza, Quattro Formaggi Pizza, Ortolana Pizza, San Daniele Pizza, and Capricciosa Pizza.
  • Chicken: Chicken takes classic Italian forms, including breaded cutlets, tomato-and-cheese preparations, artichoke dishes, and saltimbocca. Examples include Chicken Alla Pizzaiola, Chicken Carciofi, Chicken Milanese, Chicken Parmigiana, and Saltimbocca Di Pollo.

Additionally, explore Salads, Seafood, and Ice Cream.

What meals do you serve?

We serve Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

Where are you located?

We are located in Sarasota, FL at 7515 S Tamiami Trl

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Gulf Gate Estates, White Beach, Point O'Rocks, Vamo, Palmer Ranch, South Gate Ridge, Ridge Wood Heights, Sunnyland, South Sarasota, Siesta Key, Bee Ridge, South Trail, Southgate, Osprey, Sarasota Springs, Pinecraft, Sarasota, Lake Sarasota, Fruitville, and Tatum.

Our location

Map showing the location of Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria on 7515 S Tamiami Trl in Sarasota
Loading today's hours...