Cakes, gelato and filled pastries make desserts a sweet finish at Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria in Sarasota, with pickup available.
Order onlineProfiteroles
$12.00
Cream-filled choux pastry puffs served as a classic dessert.
“Best Italian restaurant in Sarasota! Family run business that treats customers like welcomed guests into their home. Haven't had Italian food this great and fresh outside of Italy. And the selection of appetizers, main courses and desserts has something for everyone, not to mention the amazing daily specials.”
Delizia al limone
$12.00
Dome-shaped sponge cake is filled and coated with lemon cream.
“Great local family run Italian restaurant. Great service and delicious food . The branzino is awesome. They have a large selection of wines and don’t leave without trying g their desserts ! Lava cake is the best in town .”
Mini Key Lime Pie
$12.00
A mini pie with a graham cracker base, cheesecake, and key lime glaze.
“Absolutely wonderful all around. Highly recommend this place. They make their deserts every day. I love gorgonzola gnocchi and it's so tough to find and theirs was out of this world. My 2nd favorite is tiramisu which is rarely made in house. Theirs is and it's out of this world good.”
At Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria, desserts include sponge cake layered with pistachio and ricotta creams, plus shortcrust pastry with lemon-hinted pastry cream, pine nuts and almonds.
Cannolo is filled with ricotta and chocolate chips. Lava Cake pairs moist chocolate cake with a creamy, rich chocolate heart. Lemon sorbe’ features refreshing sorbetto served in the natural fruit shell.
Visit us in Sarasota for dine-in, pickup or delivery. Spumone Bomba combines strawberry, pistachio and chocolate gelato, coated with chocolate and finished with a drizzle of white chocolate.
Gelato Affogato Al Caffe
$14.00
Three gelato flavors are topped with espresso and whipped cream.
“We had a wonderful dinner. Service was excellent! Food delicious. Erik, our server, was very helpful in recommendations and made us laugh. For dessert the expresso Italian ice cream was to die for. I’ll definitely be going back. Hidden gem for sure!”
Pistachio Cake
$10.00
Pistachio and ricotta creams layer with sponge cake under crushed nuts.
“This is absolutely worth a try! Family-owned and intimate table settings ensure the ambiance is what you’re looking for in a lovely evening. The service was outstanding. Alfredo was charming and provided the specials for the evening. The Osso bucco with risotto was cooked to fall-off the bone perfection. Gnocchi is house-made and all were soft as pillows. From the fresh foccia to the pistachio cake and the most delicious cappuccino, the meal was phenomenal. No pictures of entrees because they were eaten too quickly! I will be back again soon! Meatballs, burrata, beef carpaccio as appetizers were delicious.”
Tiramisu’ Homemade
$10.00
Homemade tiramisu layers coffee-soaked sponge with mascarpone cream.
“Maestrale is a fabulous lovely family owned restaurant. The food is fantastic especially the homemade tiramisu. There is an extensive menu with wonderful Italian specialties. The atmosphere is warm and inviting with white table cloths. The service is excellent. I highly recommend Mastrale.”
Cannolo
$12.00
One crisp pastry shell is filled with ricotta and chocolate chips.
Cappuccino Truffle
$12.00
Cappuccino gelato holds espresso beneath coffee meringue sprinkles.
Chocolate Cake
$12.00
Chocolate cake with hazelnut and chocolate creams has a crunchy center.
Chocolate Truffle
$12.00
Zabaione cream sits inside chocolate gelato with caramelized hazelnuts.
Crostata della Nonna
$10.00
Shortcrust tart with lemon pastry cream, pine nuts, almonds, and sugar.
Gelato
$12.00
Vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate Italian ice cream with whipped cream.
Lava Cake
$10.00
Moist chocolate cake surrounds a creamy, rich chocolate center.
Lemon sorbe’
$12.00
Lemon sorbet is served inside its natural fruit shell.
Spumone Bomba
$12.00
Three gelato flavors coated in chocolate with a white chocolate drizzle.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
